Watch your favourite TV shows on MSN Video Player now © MSN

Underrated: Madonna

Underrated: Madonna
Now don’t get us wrong. We’re not about to hail the Material Girl as the next Meryl Streep. However, neither are we ready to follow the lead of every other cynical, jaded hack and dismiss Madonna Louise Ciccone as an upstart who doesn’t know one end of the camera from the other. Yes, a lot of her big-screen outings have been fatally compromised by poor scripts, studio interference and a worrying uncertainty of purpose. But as tempting as it is to heap all the blame for their failure on her well-toned shoulders, we’re not going to. Because quite frankly, Madonna is a much better actress than she’s given credit for.
Madonna
 
This may seem a strange thing to say of a woman who got paid only $100 for her first feature, 1985’s A Certain Sacrifice, and who subsequently tried to stop it being released. And even stranger when one considers that some of her later efforts - Basic Instinct-style crime yarn Body of Evidence, for example, or the desert island sexathon which was 2002’s Swept Away - received the kind of opprobrium usually reserved for Nazi war criminals.

Delve deeper, though, and you’ll find gems in the slurry. And even the films that don’t succeed on their own terms - the much-derided Shanghai Surprise, perhaps, or 2000’s custody drama The Next Best Thing - at least have her natural vivacity and conviction to recommend them. Most of us know her screen career best for 1987's Who's That Girl. Goofball comedy as it unashamedly was, it showed a comedic talent no-one expected from the voice of La Isla Bonita.
Who's That Girl?
 
In many ways, Madge is as much a victim of typecasting as anything else. Had she not so brilliantly cemented her kooky wild child persona in 1985 indie Desperately Seeking Susan - the movie that 20 years on still comes closest to capturing that alluring combo on sexual allure and girlish vulnerability - she might have found it easier to confound expectations in her follow-up projects. Certainly audiences found it hard to accept her as a comic-book vamp in 1990’s Dick Tracy or as a gum-chewing female baseball player in A League Of Their Own. If they did, though, it was their loss, the singer-cum-actress revealing an eye-catching talent for colourful support that suggested her future lay more in character parts than in leading roles.
Evita
 
Not that the latter were beyond her, as her startling turn as Eva Peron in Evita proved (that she missed out on an Oscar nod for the musical must surely rate as one of the Academy’s most flagrant injustices). If Madonna is to be congratulated for anything, though, it’s her willingness to collaborate with her generation’s most singular cinema talents. Abel Ferrara, Wayne Wang, Spike Lee: all have benefited in some capacity from her patronage. The trend continues in 2007 with Luc Besson’s Arthur And The Invisibles, an animated fantasy in which she can be heard - wait for it - as a cartoon elf. Now who says Mrs Ritchie has no sense of humour?
 
 
By Neil Smith
 
Neil's views and opinions are expressed as his own and MSN neither endorses or necessarily agrees with the statements made in Neil's columns. MSN disclaims any and all liability for the views expressed in Neil's columns.
 
Picture Gallery: The Worst Blockbusters Ever!
Rate this article: PoorPoorNot GoodOkGoodExcellentExcellent
Your rating helps other users gauge the value of an article
... opens a new window

MORE ON MSN MOVIES

The Green Zone (Image © Universal)
Green Zone

Trailer: Matt Damon is reunited with Bourne director Paul Greengrass in this slick new military thriller set for release in March 2010.

OUT THIS WEEK

  • An Education (E1 Entertainment)An Education

    Word-of-mouth buzz is spreading about this charming story of unlikely lovers. Meet Carey Mulligan in her breakout role in new British hit An Education.

  • Fantastic Mr Fox (Twentieth Century Fox)Trailer: The Fantastic Mr Fox

    Video: George Clooney is doing what he does best in the new stop-motion animation from Wes Anderson - being smooth.

Watch your favourite TV shows on MSN Video Player now © MSN

TOP FEATURES

entertainment movies article related
en-gb

QUESTION OF THE WEEK

  1. What will happen next in the Russell Brand/Katy Perry romance?

Vote to see results

Click here to see results without voting

  1. What will happen next in the Russell Brand/Katy Perry romance?
    1. They’ll split up by Christmas
      21%
    2. They’ll get engaged
      17%
    3. Russell will cheat on Katy
      22%
    4. Katy will get pregnant
      9%
    5. A sex tape will be leaked
      19%
    6. They'll record a duet
      3%
    7. She’ll kiss a girl… and like it
      9%
20927 responses, not scientifically valid, results updated every minute.

Top Story

Top Story

Play our Search Supremo Movie Quiz
Search Supremo Movie Quiz

No one could possibly complete this quiz alone, but with the help of Live Search you might just be able to... maybe.

Top Story

Play our Movie Mash-Up game
Movie Mash-Up Game

Click the squares to gain points and guess who the actor hiding is...

Top Story

Play our brilliant new game Movie Trumps
Movie Trumps

Play our fantastically addictive game Movie Trumps. Pitch great films off against each other to get on our high score table...

Follow MSN Entertainment on Facebook (Image © Twitter, Facebook)
Join us on MSN Entertainment

Become a fan of MSN Entertainment on Facebook, get instant updates by following us on Twitter and find out how to get news, views and reviews on the move with entertainment on your mobile.

Play Movie Trumps